FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   American Airlines | AAdvantage (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/american-airlines-aadvantage-733/)
-   -   Impact of merger transition on ongoing DFW mess? (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/american-airlines-aadvantage/1529227-impact-merger-transition-ongoing-dfw-mess.html)

Stripe Dec 9, 2013 12:06 pm

Impact of merger transition on ongoing DFW mess?
 
I see on flightstats that AA is still cancelling the majority of departures out of DFW. Just curious whether anyone has any insight on the impact (positive or negative) the management transfer has had on their ability to cope. The whole mess certainly tarnishes the shine I would think they would have wanted on today's announcement.

wcj1 Dec 9, 2013 1:00 pm

I would say that it is more about the Texas inability to cope with bad weather. I flew out of DFW Saturday morning and I always amazed that they do not put the snow plow blade directly against the road. I know it is hard on the road, but I never experienced the snow/ice/sand mixture texture on the roads up north as opposed to here.

nall Dec 9, 2013 1:31 pm

The south doesn't deal with snow well. When I lived in Atlanta, the whole city would practically freak out when it happened.

MSPeconomist Dec 9, 2013 1:40 pm


Originally Posted by nall (Post 21933612)
The south doesn't deal with snow well. When I lived in Atlanta, the whole city would practically freak out when it happened.

It's not just the traditional south. DC and Philly don't cope well with snow either.

formeraa Dec 9, 2013 1:54 pm

Having worked for AA for 5 years back in the 1990's, I would say that DFW doesn't cope well with extremely cold weather and, particularly, ice storms. This has very little to do with AA. With the merger, they could actually move the hub to PHX (where it's just merely a bit cool).

CDKing Dec 9, 2013 2:13 pm


Originally Posted by nall (Post 21933612)
The south doesn't deal with snow well. When I lived in Atlanta, the whole city would practically freak out when it happened.

Feels like yesterday but, I remember a few years ago a threatened winter stom on ATL, DL proactivley cancelled a ton of flights. I dont think there's really a way to avoid it.


Originally Posted by formeraa (Post 21933801)
With the merger, they could actually move the hub to PHX (where it's just merely a bit cool).

Well after 3 years

fordan Dec 9, 2013 2:16 pm


Originally Posted by MSPeconomist (Post 21933683)
It's not just the traditional south. DC and Philly don't cope well with snow either.

Eh, Philly has snow on the ground for a good part of the winter many years. Not as well someplace like Buffalo or Rochester NY does, but Philly copes. I believe issues at PHL during bad weather have more to do with PHL being the busiest northeast airport from DC up to Boston.

youvesaiditall Dec 9, 2013 5:49 pm


Originally Posted by Stripe (Post 21932946)
I see on flightstats that AA is still cancelling the majority of departures out of DFW. Just curious whether anyone has any insight on the impact (positive or negative) the management transfer has had on their ability to cope. The whole mess certainly tarnishes the shine I would think they would have wanted on today's announcement.

Can't speak for this last storm, but the last time DFW had a number of cancellations due to an Ice Storm (that never happened) right before thanksgiving this year, the AA agent at CLT rebooked me immediately on a Direct Flight to my final destination without me even asking. Very pleasantly surprised.

CPRich Dec 9, 2013 6:15 pm


Originally Posted by Stripe (Post 21932946)
Just curious whether anyone has any insight on the impact (positive or negative) the management transfer has had on their ability to cope.

I'm fairly certain that the Legal and Executive groups aren't managing things on the ground in Dallas, and would bet a pretty large sum that the legal closure of the merger today had zero impact on the in-/ability to deal with weather at DFW.

maggie08 Dec 9, 2013 9:24 pm


Originally Posted by wcj1 (Post 21933362)
I flew out of DFW Saturday morning and I always amazed that they do not put the snow plow blade directly against the road. I know it is hard on the road, but I never experienced the snow/ice/sand mixture texture on the roads up north as opposed to here.


Originally Posted by nall (Post 21933612)
The south doesn't deal with snow well. When I lived in Atlanta, the whole city would practically freak out when it happened.


Originally Posted by MSPeconomist (Post 21933683)
It's not just the traditional south. DC and Philly don't cope well with snow either.

I understand where y'all are coming from, but you're missing that this was *not* snow. You can't just scrape it away. Putting a snow plow directly on the ice covered road is an idea that makes sense in theory, until you've actually tried it. You'd need someone to come through and jackhammer grooves/cracks in the ice every few feet before that would work.



Originally Posted by maggie08 (Post 21933952)
I think maybe there are a lot of assumptions in our conversation about people understanding different types of precipitation, and why a snow storm is drastically different than an ice storm.

So in case your grade school science teachers were like mine :rolleyes:, here's a brief review.

All precipitation starts as fluffy ice crystals way up in the clouds where the temps are below freezing. If you are in a sufficiently cold climate, such that the atmosphere is below freezing all the way down, those same fluffy ice crystals mound up on the ground, and kids make snowmen. You can plow, shovel, sweep, and even blow it away.

However, if you live in a slightly warmer climate like Texas, that then randomly gets hit with a cold front, you end up with the atmosphere in layers: freezing temps in the upper layers as it is universally, and then a stratified lower level that has a warmer layer that rises and a colder layer at the ground. Ie, those fluffy ice crystals must pass through a warmer layer in the middle.

As they do, the ice crystals melt and congeal into rain when they hit the >32F layer, and then refreeze when they hit the lower colder layer either on the ground or just above. This puts a rock hard, frozen glaze on every surface that is extremely slick. Often the molecules are so tightly and regularly arranged, the ice is perfectly transparent. This CANNOT be plowed, shoveled, swept, or blown away.
There do exist some ice graters that basically cut ridges through the ice, but the process is extremely slow and time consuming. And when the heavens are actively falling down while you're working, not much you can do.

Additionally, and ice glaze is MUCH more dense than snow. The amount of salt you would have to pour onto the ground to adequately interrupt the molecular interaction of the actively falling freezing rain is astronomical.

I work in a hospital west of DFW. The same storm hit us Thursday morning, and we had ambulance crews turning back after attempting to answer 911 dispatch crews. AMBULANCES. Canceling runs.

This isn't just a matter of AA not being prepared, or DFW not having enough snow plows. Of course, there's always room for improvement in anything, but I think there may not be an appreciation for the gravity of the situation.

Although what was supposed to be a mere 22h overnight segment run for me including 3 stops in DFW has now turned into what will be, before I'm home, a 6 day (5 hotel nights, plus a rental car, target run for basics, missing work, and a ridiculous amount of eating whatever crap food is open) ordeal, AA absolutely has done the right thing by canceling flights in droves, and I stand by their outstanding performance over this horrendous weekend.


Himeno Dec 10, 2013 12:29 am


Originally Posted by MSPeconomist (Post 21933683)
It's not just the traditional south. DC and Philly don't cope well with snow either.

They appear to be dealing with it better then London would.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 1:19 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.