I am there in early May, and will update on the window / noise situation.

I have been to book in person at the hotel, as I could not book on the website for some reason or other.

I would think Friday and Saturday nights would be the riskiest for noise.

I stayed there last week and I can honestly say it was the worst hotel experience I have had in some time. I am a Le Club Accor member and booked through the website. I prepayed my reservation. I arrived to a very tiny lobby with two clerks using laptops. I stood there waiting to check in while other people went in front of me to claim left luggage. One of the two clerks left to go fetch luggage, leaving one clerk to deal with customers. Only after I was the only one standing there did the clerk look up from his laptop. "Are you waiting for someone?' he asked.

I was given a small, shabby and noisy room. Not worth the money I paid.

I was there for four nights and must have walked in and out of the front door a couple dozen times. At no time did anyone at the desk look up from their computer to say "hello" or "good morning."

There was no doorman, no concierge, no bellman. It is not a four star hotel.

I have sent back my Le Club Accor card. They can keep the points. I feel cheated by Accor Hotels. I will take my business elsewhere.

So based on one bad experience, you throw away a whole chain with 4300 hotels worldwide ?? :confused: :rolleyes:
Be prepared to not stay anywhere, because I know a lot of bad to very bad Hilton, Sheraton, Hyatt, Mariott, etc etc hotels.

Just another rant to be honest. Why do people bother when it helps no one. I already looked at this property up online.
It is expensive because of its location very central but cheap compared to Sofitel St James which is really pricey.

I have seen the rooms online and was not overly impressed and from the details actually sounded small.
Hence I traded the central London location to get a location not far from the city center at Novotel Canary wharf where the price suited the expectation
of a more decent room/suite. Not cheap still but the location was not as expensive.

I am also having to keep my expectations lowish for New York Sofitel as again it is the location which is expensive.
Spending 600 aud per night however and maybe I will need to do plenty of tipping on top of that.

Can I ask others if tipping at Sofitel New York is required? Do they pay the staff more a European like salary or just like most hotels in USA where tips are essential to top up their income?
Cheers!

Yes the rates in the center of the city just want to make me vomit for what they offer. Airport Sofitels are very reasonable however. Yes the restaurant I think is good however it may not be everyone's taste.

On another note regarding the Victory House, I have a Friday night in October I'm looking to stay (for the first time) at this property. Rate is around 200 GBP. Does this sound like a good rate? It's a superior room and I'll be plat by that time. Thanks!

OK good that we're back on topic ;).
200 GBP is certainly not bad for central London. I hope your stay will be OK. Please report here.

Mod note: Sofitel NYC related posts have moved here: https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/acco...-new-york.html

starflyergold
Le Club Accorhotels forum moderator

Just had the inclusive breakfast at the hotel.( Its a bit confusing as basically the inclusive breakfast seems to be a full English plus the cold selection of fruits and meats on offer - the menu has different options at differing prices but we were told anything on menu ) I will do a full review later, but just have to say that tipping was seen ( £10 ) for the breakfast service from an American couple.

Very small from personal experience - don't think we got an upgrade but were told we did.

Victory House
 

Introduction Victory HouseOverall we enjoyed our short one night stay. However there was just a few too many slight niggles to have made the stay stress free and enjoyable. We are unsure if we received a room upgrade.It took a few minutes to find the entrance to the hotel. They are in a listed building, so not allowed a full sign. The name of the hotel is however shown on the door mat. You had to know where it was to see it.( For future reference it is opposite the Premier Inn ).Checkin was slow. The computer system was apparantly "down", and things had to be done by hand and a laptop.The reception area was no more than a coridore which at times looked and acted like a left luggage office for a taxi compnay. We were allocated our rooms on the top floor. I was mistaken for a maintance person as I kept beeing asked for the master key for the rooms by members of the hotel. The room ( and hotel ) were very hot. There was no opening windows in the hotel, and no air flow. The room did have air conditioning, but we had to call someone ( first time ever ) to show us how to operate it. It did then work.The room lacked a chair or two and some working space for a laptop and plug sockets - but then it had a massive central piller making the room lay out in an already cramped and small room very difficult. The TV was attached to the piller and the bed was wedged up against this.View from the top floor room was of a big peice of stonework. ie, no view. There was also no Nespresso machine or anything other than a bottle of water and 1/4 pint of milk in the room fridge.This is an upmarket top end hotel in a prestigius location. The service and standards let it down. We did not see any door persons.Alarm call. Booked with reception and it was written down. However we did not receive it - computer error was the excuse.They advertise a turn down and room cleaning service twice a day. Not provided.The water pressure was very very poor.There was no welcome gift in room for Platinum members.Fruit bowl had over ripe fruit. Amenity kits and extra shower gel had to be asked for ( good qulaity though )Breakfast was included in the room rate, but this was very confusing to the staff in the resturant. ( the computer was still down )The dining area is so small ( it is called a peteite resturnat by name ) that breakfast was being served in the reception areaI felt embarrised that we did not tip ( £10 was given by table next to us )Breakfast staff were very friendly and amenable - but also very very forgetfull. It took many attements to be served basic breakfast items such as tosat - and this was cold and just piled on a plateThe full English I ordered was poor value ( it was advertised at £24 ) and the eggs benedict were served on what appered to be stale muffins( By contrast the Sofitel St James was similar in price breakfast and faultless )The French pastries were the smallest I have ever seen, and also were not as fresh as they could have been.The hotel is still experiancing ongoing construction / matanince work and the workmen seemed to have filled the very small rception area making it unusable for receiving visitors. There was no other lounge / guest space.We had asked for a late checkout, but were disturbed by the cleaner at 11:30am asking us to vacate the room.Twice. Not enjoyable or nessasary.On the positive the bed it self was very confatable, and we had a good nights sleep. We did not suffer any noise from outside but this was a monday night.There was no pillow menu. This hotel is not the MGallary standard, but it is in a very central location, and is considerably cheaper ( £200 per room compared to £350 plus ) than other hotels in the area.

Thank you guys for your reviews of this hotel. Clearly, I prefer to stick to Novotel Canary Wharf even if the location is not not as good as this one for tourism of course. Sofitel St James is very nice but too expensive for my personal budget.

Thanks for this review. This hotel was convenient and good price for a business stay I have in a few weeks but based on this I will spend 20 EUR more and go to Doubletree (the 20 EUR more will cover for the included breakfast).