The LAN Premium Business hard product is IMO the best J seat within OW. Acres of pitch, fully flat, 15.4" widescreen with AVOD that works. Big fluffy pillows and duvets - the best nights sleep aboard an aircraft i've ever had was LAN J MIA-SCL.

Catering left a little to be desired - far from the excellent reports of old that spoke of some of the best catering in the air.

QF has a very comfortable seat for lounging but just doesn't work for me as a bed. I had a fitfull nights sleep on my only QF longhaul experience on SYD-LAX-JFK and I generally have no problems sleeping anywhere - think my record is about 18 hours of sleep in whY SYD-LHR, mind you lack of sleep for 72 hours may have helped, perhaps it was more of an alcohol induced slumber!

Catering and service were both excellent, albeit I have a very small sample number i.e. 2 legs! I prefer a much more casual style of service which I think QF do very well whilst remaining professional.

Its a tough call, but I think the LAN Premium Business would edge it for me.