I'm not an air warrior like many of you, but I do my fair share of domestic and TATL flights a year and have for many years. you regulars likely have a better perspective on this than I do.
I do agree with others that this move is likely to make boarding a bigger mess than it is right now as everyone fights for overhead bin space. And, I also believe the airlines have to do something to cover shyrocketing costs...but let's get real.
Strictly from a Customer Service (sorry, I had to say it)...and PR perspective...it seems just plain dumb to continue to tack on these annoying fees. It seems to me that ratcheting up fuel surcharges is legit...everyone's dealing with it at home, at work and would make the connection with flying. Unless, of course, I'm completely naive and it's really not about covering increaed fuel costs but just an excuse to make a few extra bucks.