FlyerTalk Forums - View Single Post - Probable Cause Not Required For Laptop Searches at US Border
Old Apr 24, 2008 | 4:47 am
  #15  
SchmeckFlyer
All eyes on you!
20 Years on Site
 
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: BRU (SEA, JNB)
Programs: Mucci Reperateur des Coeurs Brises
Posts: 4,120
Originally Posted by Kibison
It appears this was a non-UK citizen being searched in the UK. I have no problem with extensive searches of foreigners.

Do you have any reports of countries other than the US that treats its own citizens in this way? (Western Democracies, not China, Iran, or NK)
Why are the rights to individual privacy of foreigners any different than those of citizens? I personally believe in a universal approach to civil (and social) rights, with little to no exception (and I certainly would not make airport and customs inspections one of them). From a practical point of view, as soon as you start placing people into different "categories" that enjoy various limits on and degrees of freedoms, your own freedoms (as a citizen) are automatically falliable and can be modified/nullfied at any moment.

Besides that, in the end, all these searches and invasions of privacy are in the name of security, protecting our borders, protecting agriculture, protecting commerce, whatever. A citizen is just as capable of carrying kiddie porn or contaminated soil as an evil foreigner.

Furthermore, in the US your right to re-enter your country of citizen does not extend to a right to carry/import contraband and the like anyway. So I think the argument that allowing searches of foreigners while waiving citizens through it not only a violation of basic rights principles but also very ineffective policy of which no good can come.

All or nothing IMHO.
SchmeckFlyer is offline