I don't buy "lounge of the year". Many of the other lounges on the list beat the PC on food alone.

Along that line, both the Dilmun (BAH) and DCA (DXB) lounges are nice, but I would give the nod to the DCA for the food. (Although, the restroom/shower at Dilmun is fantastic.)

I guess this is a case of the sum total, but I still don't see how a PC can compete on cheese and crackers v. a hot full buffett (DCA) where seating and ambiance is equal.

Actually, I'd even consider the LHR Holidek above the PC just for the layout with the sports deck and the top floor observation area.

YMMV
DLM