If members of the general FlyerTalk population feel that Randy's decision was an error in judgment, it would certainly be appropriate for the TB to recommend he reconsider that decision. Afterall, the entire purpose of the TB is to advise Randy of the wishes of the members who elected them.
If you are going to have the Talkboard ask it's boss to reconsider himself, I might pick something a bit less, well, hammered-into-stone than a 4 year old decision which was recently affirmed and implemented.
Much less one that has
zero negative consequences for Randy, and a ton of upside as time rolls on.