I may be totally wrong here and if I am I sincerely apologise.
From my very limited understanding of Islam and Judaism I've always thought that Kosher and Halal meat was prepared the same way.
If so is there a Jewish steak restaurant in New York you could have your special dinner at?
There is a fantastic Jewish Steak place in NYC(Brooklyn ?)
Sammy's Romanian Steak House.
However-the request was for Halal and not Kosher and they are different.