Originally Posted by
mattkorey
I'm sure you can't completely compare the two, but in terms of if you had to choose one, which would be the one that is more of a can't miss. This is of course asked of people who have been to both or at least one of them. We are going to be over in Riome in late April/early May and wanted to add a few places. I know Capri is closer, but we are going to Istanbul as well I believe, so that part is not as much of an issue. Any insights are welcome and I know we FT-ers are an insightful lot.
Both are exquisite and have much to offer. However, how much total time have you allocated for the trip? Santorini will take a LOT more time to get to/from than Capri. If all you are contemplating is a weekend, then you might well find Capri the better choice.
Regardless of your decision, start booking a hotel, etc... ASAP. By late April/May both sites are very, very busy.