Some comments in another thread got me to thinking about comparing the various cruise lines against something many FT’ers are very familiar with: Hotel Chains.

As background, I’ve taken a couple dozen cruises but certainly have not been on all the cruise lines. But I do try to keep up with what’s happening in the industry and do lurk and post on several cruise IBB’s.

Here’s my take and I’m certain that YMMV:


Ritz-Carlton, Four Seasons Category: Seabourn, Silverseas, Crystal, Radisson and possibly Cunard depending on cabin category.

Marriott, Hilton, Sheraton Category: Holland-America, RCCL and Celebrity.

Holiday Inn, Ramada Inn Category: Princess, NCL, Carnival, and Disney.


Now I realize this is not exactly a scientific comparison. A good or bad experience with one hotel or ship can cloud your judgment of the whole chain or cruise line.

Curious as to how you would rank the various cruise lines above including any I may have overlooked.