I used to think that until the TalkBoard debate last month changed my mind. People will find a way to talk about what they want to talk about, and it's better to give them a place to do so. It reduces the moderation workload in the points and miles forums.
Originally Posted by
RichMSN
To me, FlyerTalk will always be about community first and foremost with a side dish of miles and points. I'd be bored silly otherwise. I know others feel that way, too, and I don't think those members, many of whom are quite helpful in the points and miles forums, should be marginalized by being told what FT should be to them.
Excellent points
nsx and
RichMSN. People will find ways to broaden their social experience. By providing a structure (via avatars, etc.) there is better control, versus members finding their own workarounds.
Originally Posted by
ClueByFour
Or, we accept the fact that FT is about miles and points and that things like avatars, reputation, and such are noise.
FlyerTalk needs to evolve, and I find it disheartening that some don't even want to consider an update to similies. Younger (ie: future FlyerTalkers) have much higher expectations for their online experiences, and basics like avatars, photos, and modern smilies are must-haves.
Originally Posted by
AZ Travels the World
As for input on this particular idea, I see it as an enormous waste of time and energy. I'd much prefer the TalkBoard focus on issues that enhance the core
mission of FlyerTalk, and I have a hard time seeing how an expanded range of smilies does that.
Come on, people! 
Obviously the FT focus is more targeted and richer than the empty chatter and gossip on most other sites (minus this thread of course) but there is no reason we can't keep "true to the mission" while also keeping up with the times.
.....
It's also telling that in 200+ threads there are so many misconceptions about the capabilities and customization. Everything is optional and anyone should have the ability to "ignore" avatars, smilies, etc. just as they can ignore users, links, and advertisements.