I see this very differently. I believe FT is so successful because it has remained largely true to its mission -- it's the place to come to increase your knowledge about the use of miles and points and the companies and their products that are the vehicle for earning & burning them.

For me, that is the reason I am here. And I dare say the vast majority of members (those who don't even read forums like this one, or show up at 'Dos'), would view the source of their motivation for being here the same way.

As for input on this particular idea, I see it as an enormous waste of time and energy. I'd much prefer the TalkBoard focus on issues that enhance the core mission of FlyerTalk, and I have a hard time seeing how an expanded range of smilies does that. Come on, people!