Originally Posted by
gglave
As a Canadian, I'm fine with maintaining our laws, the with the exception of US and Canadian CITIZENS.
If an American wants to cross the border s/he should be free to do so, no questions ask. Ditto Canadians into the USA. All they would need to do is show proof of citizenship.
Each country could maintain their existing rules for non-citizens of the USA and Canada.
I would support such a proposal.
In a way, sort of like the UK's relationship to the EU...the UK has not joined Schengen, so there are border controls, but there is a free movement of citizens/labor between the UK and (except for some of the new EU countries) EU.