Really, 200k? Points? Not miles? This year? Remember that miles and points are NOT the same thing. I am sure that I don't have to remind anyone here of that. However, all eggs are not equal.
There are numerous factors that go into the decisions to grant things like EVIP's. And the equation mentioned above isn't it. (That said, when you get 125k like last year). Because I value my job I'm not going not go into it further, but suffice it to say, it was not OP's miles/points only that came into the mix.