Originally Posted by
KenJohn
Depending on what you want to get out of your trip, I would suggest the big island of Hawaii itself; only because there are more options of things to do there. Oahu is too built up if you want scenic beauty. Maui is lovely but pricey and more up-market. If you want to see an actually live volcano with lava flows - Hawaii has a one or two.
All I can say is that prior to going, I really wanted to see Hawaii. Having been there, my feedback is "waste for time and money" I can get the same for a fraction of the price in Thailand or Bali.
The Hawaiian island are like the Canaries - dry beaches on the southern part of the island and lush green forests on the wet northern side of the island.
You forgot the most beautiful island of all. Kauai.
Definitely ranks right up in the beauty stakes.