Just to be clear, I am not proposing feedback for all forums or posts. Just for Coupon Connection, where people are exchanging real items with potentially large real value.

I realize that the vast majority of CC trades go well. But it seems wrong that an unscrupulous person could take advantage of this community so easily and with no apparent negative consequences.

Here's an idea... why not have a sticky where people could simply post things like "KSinNYC said her trade with Bhatnasx was good, PM if you want more details." The goal is to have a quick, easily findable list of trades that went well.