I'll vouch for Betta's. Betta's son and his wife now run the restaurant, but from what I understand, Betta still makes the sauce herself. By the way, they are my neighbors, and very nice people. I suggest trying the wood-fired pizzas.
There is also a Betta's location in Norwood, very close to Xavier University. This location cannot sell alcoholic beverages, but if you bring your own wine or beer, they can hold it and serve it to you.
Betta's Norwood - 3764 Montgomery Rd, Cincinnati - (513) 631-6836