The taste of A&W root beer changed sometime in the late 60's or early 70's. As a kid, I recall it being somehow more creamy and richer tasting.

I know it's not just me because this opinion is shared by many people I've discussed this with (and it's not a case of changing taste because so many other soft drinks have the same memorable flavor).

I've longed for something similar and have tried numerous other varieties. I'm glad this post has started so I can do some follow-up research.

This spring I visited a bar in St. Augustine FL that advertised they made their own root beer. I took my first sip with great anticipation only to be seriously disappointed. When I asked about how they made their root beer, the server told me they just added soda water to the syrup. Sheesh! Contrast this to my experience in Amish Pennsylvania. I bought a mug of real root beer at a shop that sold it by the jug. It was the real stuff, but too sweet for my taste.