FlyerTalk Forums - View Single Post - Will the dollar collapse?
View Single Post
Old Sep 22, 2007 | 2:10 am
  #36  
Sjoerd
20 Years on Site
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Amsterdam, Netherlands
Programs: KL Gold, SQ KF Gold, CX Green
Posts: 9,524
Originally Posted by kevincure
I work at the Federal Reserve and am quite familiar with how policy is being set. There is very little concern about exchange rates, and certainly nothing like a deliberate "export-driven policy" as an earlier poster mentioned. In general, PPP, or the equalization of prices across economies, tends to hold in the long run (say, 5 to 10 years). Over shorter periods, it's very difficult to know what moves exchange rates.

The only way prices will reequalize is a) higher US inflation, or b) strengthening of the dollar. The Fed spends 99% of its energy limiting inflation (and 1%, as seen this week, in preventing liquidity problems), so I would bet on b) and not a). The dollar was very, very strong in 2001 and 2002, and we're unlikely to return to that point. But something along the lines of
$1.20 - Euro
110 Yen - $
$1.25CAN - $
6 RMB - $
1.70 sterling - $
.75 AUD - $
seems fairly plausible for me a few years out.

Currency is a huge mystery. There is basically a zero chance of US default, so standard parity equations would imply that investors see a much higher real interest rate in Europe vs. the US over the next few years. Inflation is very similar in the Eurozone, Uk and US, so this implies that Europe will see much higher nominal growth than the US for the next few years. I just don't see this happening.

Finally, one more note on "export-led growth". Exports matter is small, trade-heavy countries. In the US, the exports part of GDP is very small (well under 10%), so you'd be hard-pressed to see a large gain in GDP from export growth alone.

Ok, one more note: A lot of the differential (not vs. the Euro, but certainly against the CAD) recently has been driven by huge growth in raw material prices. Canada is something like 15% minerals. The US does not have a large (relative to GDP) export industry in things like oil, nickel, etc., so some of these currency gains against the US look like old-fashioned "Dutch Disease".
I believe you forget one important element in your analysis: the fact that the USD was (de-facto) the only world reserve currency for the last 50 years or so. This has now changed and the US has to compete with the Euro-zone to attract money that needs to be parked (by governments, central banks, rich individuals, etc.) Today, some 75% of all international reserves is still in USD (legacy of the past) and this will only become less because the investors are diversifying which makes sense. China exports as much to the Euro-zone as it does to the US, so it makes sense for China to have a more balanced currency portfolio. Same for most other Asian cash-rich countries.

Add the political developments of the last 5 years which have made the US not exactly more popular around the world (and (currency) investors are just normal people, too), and you have a movement away from the USD.

The US has been living above its means for a long time. The US as a whole has been spending the money that others have saved. Some balance needs to be restored.

This does not mean the USD will get much lower. Currency markets always overshoot. I don't have a crystal ball, but my guess is that at 1.4 USD to the EUR we are close to the USD's low.
Sjoerd is offline