I am confused as to how giving out free status will dilute the product. If the person cannot earn the status, then they will more than likely not use it once they do have it. And if they do use it, it will probably only be occasionally. And if they switch completely to Hilton from another program, then so be it. If you complain about anyone posting the info here, then you should also complain about CO and AA having the agreement with HH to offer this type of benefit as those frequent flyers for whatever reason, day trips, etc. didn't have the status already.

If you think that you won't be able to get the benefits of Gold just because a few people that stay at hotels a few nights a year have gotten the status for free, then just switch to another chain.