I didn't want to do comprehensive comparison between two program. No way! I just wanted to share my experience with domestic upgrades and Hawaiian awards, no more.

As I noted it before each person should determine which program serves his/her needs best! Sorry, I don't care about Indian award tickets. I wanted to limit the discussion to three areas I mentioned.

BTW I'll be calling UA to request extension on reservation hold. With both programs, which rep you get is important since some are more accomodation than others.


------------------
Dan