I've done both Germaine's Luau and The Polynesian Culture Center. I loved them both, but for different reasons. Germaine's luau was incredible in and of itself. The show was awesome. The Polynesian Culture Center was just a great day all day. I started with all the other activities, then stayed for the luau. I thought that the food was better at the PCC, but the drinks were better at Germaine's. I also loved Germaine's because they had my relatives and I on stage with the hula girls. That, my friends, makes a big difference.