you might want to go ask at lthforum.com - there have been multiple spirited discussons there on the topic.

I know some people recommend Peoria, but I think that is more for bigger items such as ribs, briskets, etc. instead of steaks and chops.

I love Casey's but the price is too high for me for everyday use. I use Costco for stuff for myself, and only go to Casey's when I have people over.