There has been some debate in alliance's excellent trip report about whether or not international C and F passengers on non-UA flights get drink chits. In alliance's case he was in F on SQ LAX-NRT and stopped by the RCC for some drink chits, and the agent said he was not entitled to any. He believes he was, while stevenshev seems to be arguing that he was not. To add to it, he is *G, so that takes it even further. Would *G be the only factor that allows chits, or is that still not enough? Both of them make very valid arguments (see the linked thread), and the rules seem to not be completely clear. I would usually draw my own conclusion but in this case I have very rarely, if ever seen either of these posters wrong. So, who is correct?

Here are the RCC admit rules copied from the linked thread:
49NS/ * * STAR GOLD ACCESS - OA STAR ALLIANCE CUSTOMERS * *
50NS/ STAR GOLD CUSTOMERS `EXCEPT UA AND US AIR STAR GOLD)
51NS/ TRAVELING ON A SAME DAY STAR OPERATED FLIGHT
52NS/ HAVE ACCESS TO RED CARPET CLUB ON DAY OF TRAVEL
53NS/ CUSTOMER SHOULD PRESENT STAR GOLD CARD
54NS/ AND BOARDING PASS FOR STAR OPERATED FLIGHT
55NS/. * * SEE NOTE BELOW FOR UA AND US * *
56NS/ ** NOTE UA AND US STAR GOLD CUSTOMERS HAVE ACCESS
57NS/ ONLY IN CONJUNCTION WITH INTERNATIONAL TRAVEL* * *
58NS/ GUESTS MUST ENTER THE LOUNGES WITH AN ELIGIBLE
59NS/ STAR ALLIANCE GOLD MEMBER AND MUST DEPART ON A
60NS/ STAR ALLIANCE MEMBER AIRLINE BUT MAY TRAVEL ON A
61NS/ DIFFERENT FLIGHT.
62NS/ TWO DRINK CHITS SHOULD BE PROVIDED AT GATEWAY TO
63NS/ *TRANSOCEANIC* TRAVELERS ONLY
64NS/ ALL CARD HOLDERS AND GUESTS SHOULD BE TRACKED

and:

* * * UA AND STAR INTERNATIONAL TRAVELERS * * *
UNITED FIRST INTERNATIONAL AT ALL CLUBS ON SAME-DAY
TRAVEL... ONE GUEST ALLOWED... TWO DRINK CHITS SHOULD
BE PROVIDED AT THE GATEWAY.
UNITED BUSINESS INTERNATIONAL AT ALL CLUBS ON SAME-DAY
TRAVEL... NO GUESTS ALLOWED... TWO DRINK CHITS SHOULD
BE PROVIDED AT GATEWAY.

I would logically think that an LH C passenger at ORD using the RCC would get two chits, but apparently not? Any help would be appreciated!