I also enjoy Coldstone for an occasional treat. It's always busy in Gainesville - this is a college city, so students run amok. Our Coldstone employees only sing to you if you tip. They always greet you as you come in, and gives you exactly the combo you want, which is what I like... double caramel and chocolate fudge, in sweet cream ice cream, with heath bar and butterfinger mixed in...yummmmm....
I can only eat the small size as well, and go in 2 or three times a year. But it is very sweet and thick and creamy