I recently purchased the waterproof version on Max Factor's Lash Perfection Mascara. It went on okay, made my lashes look good and is definitely waterproof.
So waterproof that no matter how much Albolene cream (I've been using this stuff since I was a teenager to remove makeup and it always works), baby oil, or Almay mascara removal pads I used I couldn't get this stuff completely off. But too much staying power is not a good thing. I wound up with a Stye and had to go to my eye doctor.
I had to put compresses on my eye twice a day, couldn't wear my contacts or makeup to work, and had uncomfortable pain for nearly a week.
Think I'll give Blinc a try.