Originally Posted by
kebosabi
Like the previous poster has said, its YMMV between coffins and suites. Some prefer the former, the others latter. I tend to prefer the coffins myself, but in all honesty, F in AA is a clear disappointment to most other airlines like CX or SQ.
No, I didn't say YMMV. Most people clearly prefer the suites. I did say that some people prefer coffins when traveling with a companion.
Originally Posted by
kebosabi
What AA desperately needs is an elegant design that doesn't look like it has been concoted by Staples. I'd take the purported new F seats on the domestic JL over AA's transcon F.
AA's suite seat is just as good as the F seat on CX. The service doesn't measure up, but if you're flying US-LHR, going via HKG just so you can fly CX usually doesn't make sense. I'm not quite sure where transcons come into the suites vs. coffins debate.