Originally Posted by sstolp

No...I had actually looked at that (which is where I got the links to the seat review sites), but was hoping to get more personal opinions rather than generalisations.

For example, when I have to fly economy I would always choose a seat towards the back of the plane by the toilets, so that I can get to the loo, even if the CC are out with their trolleys. If you look at the reviews though, my favourite Y seats are usually rated very badly.