Originally Posted by CO 1E
Originally Posted by UncleDude
But then with AA's easier upgrade policy they would probably have been in First Class
Yes, which is inferior to BusinessFirst.

...but AA's F is superior to CO's Y.
It's a tough call on this one - if you're one to pay for the big seat, better service and superior in-flight experience, go with CO. If not... and you play the upgrade game… AA (or UA) offer better chances IMHO.
Just bear in mind: few airlines Y class can outrank another’s C/J class
DoggyDaddy - if you're willing to shell out the $$$ CO will sometimes do revenue upgrades to BF for 15/14. I believe they can go for anywhere from $200 - $400 / person / way -- but I certainly stand to be corrected. Anyway, can't remember all that much about them
but if you want the big seat and are willing to pay a little extra, it may behoove you to check into this.