FlyerTalk Forums - View Single Post - Best system for the student?
View Single Post
Old Oct 8, 2006 | 1:28 pm
  #15  
Solarmoon
 
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: SFO
Programs: UAL 1K
Posts: 203
Originally Posted by epi231
Having just finished my PhD, I thoroughly disagree with you! The time of a graduate student is worth much less than the time of someone "in the real world." Also, graduate school can be (and often is) very stressful and isolating, and trips away, especially to see one's romantic interest, are very well justified, IMHO.
I'm not denying the usefulness of taking trips or even going skiing as a graduate student --- I did all that when I was a graduate student. The problem is that the original poster wants to take these trips regularly in a very planned out fashion, and this strikes me as a very bad, not to mention expensive, idea. The student's mind should not be looking forward to their next trip a few weeks from now. The student needs to develop connections with his peers. And any time inspiration hits him, he needs to be able to go down to the lab or library and get working.

Basically, getting a doctorate is *supposed* to be an all-encompasing obsession and is hence inherently isolating. Why would anyone (from a developed country... I can understand how some people from poorer countries get PhDs in order to get their foot in the door immigration-wise) go for a PhD if they did not want to completely immerse themselves in the academic life for at least a few years? To get a job, it would be better to just go and get an MBA, MD, or JD.

My feeling is that he would be better off taking last minute trips as needed. Hence my recommendation to invest in a webcam. I actually think that it might be a good thing for him to have a romantic interest far away --- more time to concentrate on his research and less time spent in courting her.
Solarmoon is offline