Originally Posted by mrcimino1

Perhaps there is something fishy here.

No reference to NW flight number or actual date of the flight.

A claim to have "checked at the club" prior to the flight. Flying FC does not get you into the club, whether it is paid FC or not. This would imply a membership in the Worldclub. If someone really flys "AAalot" they would most likely have an Admiral's Club membership, but not a Worldclub membership.