they give you ten of fifteen bucks??????

Fair??? That is an INSULT.

at a penny a mile that's $15!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


And you have to ask if its fair??

They should have responded with a polite apology and stressed that this was atypical and they looked foward to doing better in the future.


OR the above and a meaningful goodwill gesture.

I think a paltry, insulting goodwill gesture is WORSE Than NO goodwill gesture.
I'm serious about this. And it is a "goodwill gesture". You are not entitled to "compensation".

If you ask me what is "fair", I would say a $200 Voucher for future travel for EACH seat.

i.e. a 10% credit for future travel.

You got less Than 1%!