The "famous" pizza places in New Haven are all a little overrated. The best pizza place, I think, is BAR on Chapel Street, where you can get fantastic microbrewed beer along with the usual brick-oven pizza.

By far the most unique and wonderful eating establishment in New Haven is Louie's Lunch. I'm not sure if it's open Wednesday nights, but if it is, you all should stop in for one of the best hamburgers on planet Earth after having a few too many martinis at Hot Tomato. (The enormous space at Hot Tomato is great, but I'm not sure about the food. I personally like Roomba--the slightly overpriced but still unmatched Cuban restaurant next to the Union League Cafe.)