In the end, I decided to mail it in today and just get a new one. It was $127 with expedited service (ugh) but I had some extra time today to go pick up an extra copy of my marriage license (I didn't like the idea of sending in my only one) and since they take passport photos at the county service center, get those done all in one-stop shopping so I figured I might as well. I didn't send it overnight like they recommend, so I'm curious to see how long it takes to get to me.