First, this was the 2nd time not the third time this has happened. Second, you appear to have been aware of the prior problem and the proposed remedy for same -- first night free and remaining nights at 1/2 price. Therefore, Hilton may argue that that is their standard response and that you had notice of the remedy before you booked the room. Third, I think Hilton's offer is quite generous and that far from considering it lame, you should accept it.

IMHO, Hilton could very easily tell you to stuff it and blacklist you from earning HHonors points. And, may I ask, what would be your remedy??

Are you going to sue Hilton over a $0 rate?? I am quite aware of the liberal attitudes amongst jurors, but do you really think that the poor idiot in the juror box is going to sympathize with you, especially since Hilton has given you a generous offer? Further, you may not obtain much sympathy since I assume you are a German national. In addition, you would have to sue in Federal Court because of diversity problems, and this is well known to be a far less hospitable place for plaintiffs. Finally, I think it quite doubtful that you will find an attorney who would be willing to take this case on a contingency basis. Therfore, you would have to put your own $$ up front to see that this was actually litigated. Although I think that the American court system has some flaws, it would be interesting to noted how you value your claim, by actually putting your money where your mouth is -- if you think it so valid and that Hilton's offer is so lame, then I hope that Hilton reneges on their offer to just you, and then we will see if you actually feel that your claim is justified.

My 2 pfennings (soon to be .02 Euros)