Originally Posted by Dovster
4. That being the case, my initial post has to be considered in the same light as any other post which says something positive about a member vs a post which is an attack on one. Is it your contention, for example, that because I can get a time out for saying "FlyerTalkerA is a babbling idiot whose posts are pure garbage" that I should also be disciplined for saying "FlyerTalkerB has made many intelligent and helpful posts"?
I think you're conflating concepts. Saying that a FTer is an idiot and saying that an FTer makes good posts is not at all like saying particular moderation in a particular instance was good or bad. You don't see the difference?