OK...thanks for the encouragement folks!
I will forge ahead.
Yes FF1, we very much liked the RC Doha. The Club Lounge is very impressive and the food presentations very much above average...though not up to Ritz New York Central Park standards. RC Dubai's strengths are the beach/pool and its small size. The rooms and public spaces were nice, but not as sharp as I expected. The finishings just werent as luxurious as most RCs/FS/MOs. The Club food there was below average vs. other RCs.