Thanks for all the replies guys. I never received an email from Eden Martinez or anyone else from AA regarding the selling of AA Miles. I actually live in NWA country (hence my username) so I don't fly American much and actually only have a few hundred miles in my account. It's possible that some of the people that bought miles from me did, but I never heard about it. Maybe the sale of coupons is frowned upon but tolerated?

The best price I found for the Dannon water was $2.47 per case. I was able to buy several thousand at that price. I had pallets of water arriving weekly on a semi. A friend and myself could load up about 100 cases at a time in a Suburban. It became a pet project to do in our free time. I donated some of it to the Red Cross, but most of it was resold (minus the coupon) for $1.50-$2.00 per case. Word travels fast when you have brand name water at $.10 a bottle. Catering companies were my biggest customers. Getting rid of the water has been easier than selling the coupons.

Thanks for the craigslist suggestion. I will definitely look into that. I know that some of the Wendy's and Cinemark coupons ended up there. Craigslist just doesn't have the exposure that eBay does.