Originally Posted by Fly AA J all the way
In theory that's the case. But there are so many screw ups with that, that it's hard to believe what's published. For example, AA.com had my BOS-SFO as drinks only in F (obviously not the case).
Indeed, AA.com has a problem with this, however Expert Flyer shows teh accurate information as has been discussed in a number of threads over teh past few months.
As for the OP's comments I think its quite ridiculous to completely give up on AA after this one little thing, especially when they have presumably done pretty well for the OP if he has flown 860,000 miles on them up to now. I have endured far worse than this on AA (i.e. one bathroom operating on a plane of over 100 people for four hours) and have never even considered giving up.