What fares are you getting SFO-SXM?
I fly PHL-SXM and NYC-SXM monthly (I have a house in AXA) and I pay ~$500 in the winter and $400 in the summer. I recenty jumped on the CO EWR-SJU $118 fare(s) and would get a $150 AA SJU-SXM fare. This would make for a lot of flying coming from SFO but you...
Gotta run, the web cafe is closing.

More later (if you want)...