Waited my 10 weeks, as requested in my confirmation email.
Called yesterday. The magazine/newspaper company said they never received the order from AA. So they took it over the phone.
I will only call it in from now on.
If the miles haven't been deducted from your account yet, the order hasn't been sent to the magazine company. Call 1-800-961-8669. Also, the WSJ is still not listed on the AA website, but still available over the phone.