Tiffy,
If this is your first Aman, you'll have a grand time! The few shortcomings that I mention in my report are for the Amanjunkies on this board (we like to compare one Aman to another in search of the ultimate Aman and get a little nit-picky in the process).
As for Amanpulo, it really is a wonderful place. Feel free to let us know if you have specific questions.
Ericka