Went back to check to see if anything had changed with a little time to process (sure.. because that always works..).. And noticed that there is an entry down at the bottom.

The original flight is still confirmed economy with no mention of any upgrade. The new entry on the bottom has me waitlisted for the upgrade. So perhaps, even though I am upgrading with paper, she put me directly onto the waitlist? Unfortunatly, no indications as to which waitlist i am on exist.... Whatever her "priority waitlist" is.. ?