Originally Posted by qasr
I'm tall, so E+ for sure. I think anyone over 6' would make the same choice... Unles they had knee defenders of course.

Me too. I'm 6'2", and not what one would even passingly refer to as thin, and had a choice between E+ middle (6B) or E- aisle on an A320 SFO-PHL a couple of months ago. The RCC agent looked at me like I was crazy when I said I'd take the middle seat, but I found that it was as comfortable as I was going get. E- is murder on my legs.
For the record, it wasn't bad at all. Not great either, of course, but not bad.