FlyerTalk Forums - View Single Post - split thread: profiling
View Single Post
Old Nov 12, 2005 | 7:09 pm
  #48  
PatrickHenry1775
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Programs: AA, WN RR
Posts: 3,122
Originally Posted by Gargoyle
I often hear American citizens talking amongst themselves in foreign languages in the check-in lines for int'l flights. Typically the parents are naturalized (foreign born) citizens travelling with their native U.S. born children. Remember, the true strength of American comes from the fact that we are the greatest melting pot, the most diverse mix of people, in the history of the world. Harassing, er, I mean ssss'ing someone just because they speak another language just adds to the international impression of American arrogance and xenophobia, which adds to anti-American sentiment world wide, and is one way we help create petri dishes where those who hate the U.S. can thrive.

Weren't the U.K. tube bombers British subjects? If they grew up in the U.K., attending school there, profiling by accent or passport would miss them.

As to profiling Muslims, how do you tell a Bosnian Muslim from a Bosnian Christian from a Bosnian Jew from a Croatian or a Serb or a Greek, Albanian, Italian, Bulgarian or Spaniard? By how they look? Or do you propose that everyone carry ID's stating their ethnic background? At what point do we stop being a free country and become a police state?

Just to confuse the discussion, the majority of suicide bombers world wide in the past dozen years were not Muslims- the biggest single group were members of the Tamil Tigers.
Then who should get SSSScreening - native born Americans speaking English or people speaking a foreign language? Intrusive searches of Americans for no reason is a quicker way to get to a police state than foreigners receiving such searches. Remember, I do not think anyone should have SSSS on his/her boarding pass getting that person a search for no reason. As Bart says, either the screening is done right the first time or else the SSSS does not add anything to security.

Regarding the Tamil Tigers, if they were in the U.S., they would not speak American English, so my suggestions would flag them for extra attention. This would not be a negative situation. We are fortunate that this group has concentrated on other targets.
PatrickHenry1775 is offline