I would put the Trellis at the top of the list. The colonial taverns are all good....I happen to like King's Arms and Shields the best...Green Leafe is great for early dinner and lunch. I would definitely try to get to Pierce's for barbeque....it is really unique. The Golden Horseshoe clubhouse (overlooking golf course near Williamsburg Inn) is delightful for lunch....they don't serve dinner. Also Barrett's Seafood near Merchant's Square at the College end of the town. Have a great trip!