I agree that there are many forums I visit rarely. I don't think there should be inflexible rules. For example, today I flew on Allegiant Air (G4), a Part 141 airline that serves maybe 25 cities but doesn't have a FF program -- or a forum here. Would that go under Miles and Points?
I didn't vote on either the Budget Travel issue nor the Religious Travel issue. I would have voted to have a single forum called Budget Travel and Travel Bidding, or maybe Travel Cheapness (so near and dear to my heart). I would have voted against establishing a Religious Travel forum, because IMHO such a forum, however well-intentioned, would/will quickly devolve into flame wars.