I recently stayed at the Park Plaza. Like you I was apprehensive after reading the reviews on priceline. Not to worry. Our experience was great, and it was the only hotel that gave me exactly the room I wanted.

If you want luxury, spend a little more and go for the 4*. But if you just need one night at the airport, the Park Plaza is great for holiday inn level accomodations. It is also a good property if you have a rental car - the downtown hotels all charge for parking.