Originally Posted by Boraxo

So far 3 stays with the Edit. Zero room upgrades in fact some of the worst rooms in the house. Supposedly all sold out properties.

But overall not any type of special treatment. I am sure Chase doesn’t care as it’s all about the benjamins. Not that Amex THC or FHR treatment is any better but they do have more properties.

Originally Posted by richarddd

We got a two category suite upgrade on our one Edit stay. It was a Four Seasons. Whether we'd have done better with a FSPP or the like is not clear. It is clear how a FSPP would answer that question

Originally Posted by emcampbe

I was upgraded in Feb. at JW Anaheim. The ‘upgrade’ was to a ‘club-level’ room. I’m unclear what the benefit of that room over a room on a different floor would be, accept for the high floor so a better view.

as for upgrades in general, I realize, whether for these kinds of programs or just for hotel status in general, it’s a bit of a gimmick. They aren’t guaranteed in most cases, so even when O book with FHR/edit, I’m not expecting anything different than I booked. I see it as a way to get a nicer hotel at a relatively affordable rate. The credit/breakfast always help, for sure. But upgrades don’t really phase me.