I'm more interested in what people like when they rate a club higher than rankings of particular clubs.

For me the things I make note of

* views are the most important thing to me, if there's no view I probably won't even bother
* if I have to go up (or down) from the main concourse level that's a big negative. I don't mind SOME stairs but, like ATL B is insanely high up and the elevators get crowded and they're slow. Escalators are annoying as I've previously noted (I will generally just walk up the escalator if possible)
* being close to the gates is a huge plus
* big clubs are kind of a turnoff to me (for reference, I would say ATL D is "big" but just barely)
* generally I don't use outstation clubs very much since I try not to get to the airport until boarding time but delays obviously happen